Antipode Online

Celebrating 50 years of publishing a Radical Journal of Geography, 1969-2019

  • Content
    • Journal Issues
    • News
    • Lecture Series
    • Interventions
    • Book Reviews
    • Video Abstracts
    • Antipode Book Series
    • The Antipode Film Project
    • Interviews
    • The Critical Classroom
    • Other
  • About Antipode Online
    • The website
    • Creative Commons copyright
    • Comments policy
    • Contact
  • About the Journal and Foundation
    • A Radical Journal of Geography
    • Editorial Collective
    • International Advisory Board
    • Antipode Foundation Ltd.
  • Institute for the Geographies of Justice
    • About the Institute
    • Apply to the Institute
    • Past Institutes
      • Athens GA, USA, 28 May – 1 June 2007
      • Manchester, UK, 18 – 22 May 2009
      • Athens GA, USA, 30 May – 3 June 2011
      • Durban, South Africa, 27 May-1 June 2013
      • Johannesburg, South Africa, 21-27 June 2015
      • Montréal, Québec, Canada, 5-9 June 2017
      • Mexico City, Mexico, 17 – 21 June 2019
      • Barcelona, Spain, 13 – 17 June 2022
  • “Right to the Discipline” grants
  • Scholar-Activist Project Awards
    • Scholar-Activist Project Awards – 2012/13 recipients
      • Challenging the “New Urban Renewal”: Gathering the Tools Necessary to Halt the Social Cleansing of Council Estates and Developing Community-led Alternatives for Sustaining Existing Communities
      • A Spatial Political Economy of Waste in Hyderabad, India: A “Geography From Below” Approach
      • Visioning the Future: Exploring Youth Participatory Video and Geographical Imagination in Zimbabwe and South Africa
      • Science for Indigenous Activism: Mapping the Impacts of Oil Companies
      • Uniting Detroiters: Coming Together From the Ground Up
    • Scholar-Activist Project Awards – 2013/14 recipients
      • Scaling Up Urban Resistance to the New Gentrification Frontier: Creating a National Campaign Network to Defend Traditional Retail Markets
      • The E14 Expedition: Building Community Through Story-Telling
      • Precarious Workmen Speaking Out: South Asian Migrant Workmen’s Diaries and Narratives as Safe Migration Resources
    • Scholar-Activist Project Awards – 2014/15 recipients
      • Re-membering Rebellion in the Forgotten East: Knowledge Coproduction as a Necessary Link in the De/fence of Ch’orti’ Territory
      • Spreading the Seed: Feminist Kurdish Revolution and Radical Epistemologies
      • The Arts and Precarity: Forging New Solidarities (A Cabaret and Workshop)
      • The Detroit Reentry Study
      • Organize! Action-Research of Global Workers for Local Victories
    • Scholar-Activist Project Awards – 2015/16 recipients
      • Mentorship as political practice: Filipino-Canadians organizing against educational abandonment in Vancouver BC
      • Peoples’ Global Action and the Alterglobalisation “Movement of Movements”: An Oral History of Transnational Organising for Today’s Struggles
      • Re-Drawing the Economy: Creating Place-Based Images That Can Travel
      • Supporting Community Research to Contest the Normalization of Extrajudicial Killings and Everyday Violence in Mathare, Nairobi
      • Indigenous Tourism Activism Hui-Trawün: Fostering spaces of self-determination and collaboration
      • The Hunger Strikers’ Handbook: Detention Abolition, From the Inside Out
    • Scholar-Activist Project Awards – 2016/17 recipients
      • Beyond Indigeneity: Rights, Resources, and Political Mobilization in Oaxaca, Mexico
      • Mapping Disappearances, Abuses, and Resistance from the Inside and Out: A Real-Time Map of U.S. Immigration Detention
      • The PDX Black Gardens Project: Reworking Portland’s Sustainability Narratives through Collaborative Oral History
      • A People’s Guide Online
    • Scholar-Activist Project Awards – 2017/18 recipients
      • Resting Safe: Houseless Community Control of Urban Space
      • Fragile Resistance on the EU Borderzone: The Peaceful Geographies of the Refugee Crisis
      • How the Roma are Fighting Back: A Diary and Guide for Resistance Against Restitutions and Forced Evictions
      • Solidarity Los Angeles
    • Scholar-Activist Project Awards – 2018/19 recipients
      • Black Feminist Spatial Imaginaries in Northeast Portland: Drawing a reconstruction, resistance, and reclamation of place
      • Pay the Rent: Re-envisioning and re-forming gentrified landscapes in Aboriginal Sydney
      • Jackson People’s School
      • The Prison Law Archive: Recovering a lost history of anti-prison struggle in California
  • International Workshop Awards
    • Regional Workshop Awards – 2012/13 recipients
      • Histories of Radical and Critical Geography
      • Regional Revolutions: Advancing Radical Geographical Scholarship and Practice Through Feminist Geography Across the Canada-US Border
      • Crises Regimes and Emerging Urban Social Movements in Cities of Southern Europe
    • International Workshop Awards – 2013/14 recipients
      • Grounding the Anthropocene: Sites, subjects, and struggle in the Bakken Oil Fields
      • Squatting houses, social centres, and workplaces: A workshop on self-managed alternatives
      • Politicizing African urban ecologies: Enabling radical geographical research practices for African scholars
      • Re-thinking Latin America development beyond neoliberalism: Toward a rediscovering/recreation of the Latino American thought on development
      • Queer Worldings: A Transnational Queer Studies Workshop
    • International Workshop Awards – 2014/15 recipients
      • Comparative Subalternities: Socio-spatial Marginalization in the Global South
      • The Role of Activists and Academics in Addressing Health and Environmental Issues Associated with Extractive Industries in Latin America and Canada
      • Old Maps, New Terrain: Rethinking Population in an Era of Climate Change
      • Space, Race, Bodies II: Sovereignty and Migration in a Carceral Age
    • International Workshop Awards – 2015/16 recipients
      • Pursuing Elusive “Win-Win” Results for Forests and People in Peru
      • Towards a Politics of Accountability: Caribbean Feminisms, Indigenous Geographies, Common Struggles
    • International Workshop Awards – 2016/17 recipients
      • Beyond Disputed and Fragmented Borders: Facilitating Co-operation between Kashmiri and Palestinian Youth Activists
      • “Let Justice Roll Down Like Waters”: The Role of Spirituality in African American Environmental Activism in the US South
      • Regional Encounter and Workshop on Radical Methodologies in Contested Places: Approaching Decolonization in Central America
      • Decolonising Settler Cities
    • International Workshop Awards – 2017/18 recipients
      • Sovereignty Expanded: Indigenous Geographies of the Contemporary American West
      • Postcolonial Difference, Strategic Solidarities: Geographies of Race, Caste, and Tribe in South Asia
      • Frontiers of Environmental Justice: Building Transoceanic Solidarity Between the Pacific, the Caribbean and the UK
      • Policing Rage in the Urban Age of Crises and Extremes
    • International Workshop Awards – 2018/19 recipients
      • Beyond Extraction: A Counter-Conference in the Heart of Extractive Capital
      • Radical Housing Encounters: Translocal Conversations on Knowledge and Praxis
      • Fund SUNY Now! Pushing Back Against Austerity in Public Higher Education
      • School for Future Urbanists: Towards Eco-Equity City Region
  • Supplementary material
    • Introducing Milton Santos and “The Active Role of Geography”
    • The Union of Socialist Geographers Newsletter, 1975-1983
  • Past activities
    • Graduate Student Scholarship
      • About the Scholarship
      • Past winners
    • The Antipode Staff Reporters

Bhopal: A personal story about forgetting and re-engaging

25th October 2012

Andy Daviesby Andy Davies, University of Liverpool

In 2004, I was a fresh-faced 20-something who, straight out of my undergrad degree, had uncritically accepted that there was a process called ‘Development’ that was worthwhile taking part in, and had ended up volunteering in Bangalore, India. This was an education in itself, and is in many ways responsible for my turn towards more radical ideas (that, however, is another story).

Whilst in Bangalore, in order to have a meeting with some other volunteers in Indore, I passed through Bhopal. Up until that point in my life, I’d been aware of something called the ‘Bhopal disaster’, which was ‘the world’s largest industrial accident’, but it hadn’t really struck me what this meant. Whilst I spent little more than an evening in the city, that was enough to get a sense of the lingering grievances about the disaster that still remained important to the people that lived there. Over the next few years, I’d kept half an eye on things to read about Bhopal, but over time had gradually paid less attention to the issue. That changed when, just prior to this summer’s Olympics in London, a number of protests were launched against Dow Chemical’s sponsorship of the Games. Sponsorship of the Games is, of course, filled with the tensions of corporate capitalism, but the campaign against Dow’s sponsorship was the latest protest against the company’s disregard for the people of Bhopal.

The Bhopal disaster, for those unfamiliar with it, was the result of a toxic gas cloud from a pesticide factory operated by Union Carbide India Limited (a subsidiary of Union Carbide). Due to a variety of safety failures within the complex (which are disputed by Union Carbide), on the evening of the 2nd / 3rd of December 1984, a toxic mixture of gases vented from one of the methyl isocyanate tanks on the site. The resulting cloud of gas was blown over the city, including some areas next to the plant which housed some of its poorest residents. The toxic cloud is estimated to have affected up to 500,000 people within the city. Thousands of people died (the exact figures are disputed, but range from 8,000 up to 25,000) and many more were permanently affected by the poisons they inhaled. Thousands of children were and are born with birth defects and genetic abnormalities. Union Carbide became a subsidiary of Dow in 2001, but since 1984, there has been a campaign (using a variety of methods, see http://theyesmen.org/blog/dow-runs-scared-from-water) to [a] provide compensation for those affected by the disaster, [b] force the company to clean up the site, which remains polluted as a result of the industrial waste produced by the facility, and [c] prosecute those who are responsible.

Dow Chemical banner, Bhopal

The long running nature of the dispute means that the campaign for justice Bhopal disaster victims has important geographical consequences that play out across spatial scales. Firstly, and most importantly, the disaster continues to have an enormous impact on the people of Bhopal at a local scale. Beyond the obvious impacts of those affected by the death family members, there are the long running health issues affecting many people (see http://www.bhopal.org), together with ongoing pollution of groundwater in the area after the site was closed, together with the effects of trauma and stress on individuals and their families.

BHOPAL (231583728)

The disaster and its management also directly impact on India at a national level and at a state level in Madhya Pradesh, as the state’s role in both initially attracting UC to the country, and the role of Indian law in the management of the disaster and the subsequent settlement made with UC is vital to the ongoing sense of grievance felt by Bhopalis.

The targeting of the Olympics also highlights how this disaster is an issue that is able to have transnational effects. Obviously, the role of UC and Dow as transnational corporations is important here, driven as they are by free trade and the nature of global capitalism. However, the Bhopal disaster has also been able to draw on what Mary Kaldor (2003) calls ‘global civil society’. Of course, the extent and spread of this civil society is debateable, yet transnational activism remains one of the few ways numerically small movements like those for justice in Bhopal can attempt to ‘up-scale’ and mobilise. Targeting major international events like the Olympics is a key strategy for gaining visibility, yet is also tied into more ‘micro-political’ activities where solidarity is constructed much more locally (something which I’ve written about in relation to the Olympics a little bit before – see Davies 2009).

The day to day work of constructing solidarity across space is done by a various actors, and in particular by what Paul Routledge has called ‘imagineers’, who do the work of stitching together seemingly disparate struggles. This happened last weekend when I attended a screening of the excellent film Bhopali as part of a Bhopal Survivors tour that is currently taking place in the UK. This was supported locally by Merseyside Asbestos Victims Support Group, Steve Tombs from Liverpool John Moores University and Nerve Magazine amongst others.

Whilst, in academia, we know a huge amount about how these movements function and how transnational activism happens, for me, this event was about more than thinking theoretically about how we can understand the tragedy of Bhopal from a geographical perspective. Instead, I spent more time thinking about my own visit to Bhopal in the past, which in turn re-energised a commitment that had waned in recent years as other, seemingly more urgent, parts of life had intervened. As a result, rather than try to make a grand point about either geography, or about Bhopal when it is only one of many examples of injustice around the world (as we are all too aware), I simply want to point out that, without the Olympic protests earlier this year, I probably wouldn’t have re-engaged with Bhopal as an issue in my life. This is now something which I’m trying to change (and if you’d like to get involved in organising something, then let me know!), but I think it is worthwhile for everyone to reflect, once in a while, on the struggles and causes that we have taken part in, and those that we have moved on from or forgotten about, and whether it is worthwhile re-engaging with them.

References

Davies A D (2009) Ethnography, space and politics: Interrogating the process of protest in the Tibetan Freedom Movement. Area 41(1):19-25

Kaldor M (2003) Global Civil Society. London: Polity

Tweet

Share

  • Email
  • Print
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Related

Tags

This article has been tagged with the following:

  • 2012 London Olympics
  • Bhopal
  • development
  • disaster
  • Dow Chemical
  • environmental justice
  • geographical scale
  • India
  • jumping scale
  • law
  • London Olympics
  • Olympics
  • pollution
  • protest
  • social justice
  • the state
  • transnational activism
  • transnational social movements
  • Union Carbide

Cancel reply

Recent Tweets

  • RT @WilliamWConroy: 1. 🚨New article just out!🚨 “Fanon’s Mobilities: Race, Space, Recognition” is now online via @antipodeonline Here, I…

  • Video abstract — "The 'Environment Making State' and Climate Change: The French ‘Cat Nat’ Reinsurance Scheme Under… https://t.co/52aoum35Mw

  • Volume 55, Number 1 – our January 2023 issue – out now, including eight #openaccess articles https://t.co/tWXMzpZ4KX https://t.co/qpOvuT1oYO

Sign Up

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 1,710 other subscribers.

Publications

  • Journal Content
  • Book Series

Follow Us

  • © Copyright 2023 Antipode Foundation
  • Privacy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Cookie Preferences